Leaked Pentagon Docs Put U.S.-South Korea Alliance in Highlight

Espionage is a behavior well-baked into U.S. historical past—although at instances it has created complications with allies who’ve discovered themselves on the opposite finish of American spying.

In 2013, it was revealed that the NSA and CIA had been tapping Germany’s then-Chancellor Angela Merkel’s telephone for years. As extra reviews of U.S. prying into the German government emerged months later, an American intelligence official was even asked to leave the embassy in Berlin over allegations of spying, with Merkel herself describing the state of affairs as a “clear contradiction to trusting cooperation.”

And Germany isn’t the one ally that’s felt aggrieved: the French authorities was outraged in 2015 after information broke that the U.S. had been spying on then President François Hollande and his predecessors. Hollande known as his American counterpart Barack Obama and mentioned he obtained an assurance that Washington would restrict its “unacceptable” spying “among allies.”

Maybe unsurprisingly, that behavior hasn’t stopped. In current weeks, a scattering of allegedly leaked Pentagon documents, some purportedly solely meant to be accessible to these with excessive U.S. safety clearance, have been posted throughout social platforms like Discord, Telegram, and Twitter. TIME couldn’t independently confirm how genuine the paperwork have been, however they reportedly included info on U.S. assessments of the battle in Ukraine in addition to intelligence on diplomatic allies.

Extra from TIME

A minimum of two of the paperwork, the Korea Herald reports, detailed inner discussions amongst South Korea’s officers in regards to the U.S. pressuring the East Asian nation to assist provide weapons to Ukraine amid Seoul’s hesitancy. The knowledge was reportedly based mostly partially on intercepted communication indicators.

Yang Uk, a navy and protection analyst on the Asan Institute for Coverage Research in Seoul, tells TIME that official ties between the 2 nations is not going to essentially be gravely affected after this incident, however the concept of espionage amongst allies could harm normal South Korean opinion concerning the U.S. The workplace of South Korea’s President Yoon Suk-yeol was fast to assert on Monday that “the alliance continues to be sturdy,” however Yang tells TIME: “I feel the Korean public is actually upset that the U.S. just isn’t trusting South Korea.”

A Pentagon official told CNN the U.S. Protection Division is investigating the doc leak, and South Korea’s authorities on Sunday said it’ll talk about “points raised” by the exposé. Protection officers in Seoul have additionally repeated that South Korea’s coverage on Ukraine is not going to change.

South Korea has been very cautious about instantly supplying weapons to Ukraine—particularly since South Korean regulation restricts the export of arms that will “affect” international peace. “We’re placing efforts to keep up peaceable, good relations with each nation on this planet, together with Russia,” Yoon told reporters in October.

Yang says that the publicization of the paperwork, nonetheless, makes cooperation with the U.S., particularly on Ukraine coverage, much more fraught. “Even when the President desires to assist—it’s actually laborious to do [now],” he says.

The espionage subject has already been taken up by the nation’s opposition occasion. The Democratic Celebration of Korea (DPK), which controls the Nationwide Meeting, has been at finest lukewarm about getting concerned within the Ukraine disaster, and it’s turn out to be extra vocal about U.S. interference. On Twitter on Monday, the occasion characterised the alleged American spying on Seoul as “a critical violation of nationwide sovereignty.” One DPK member, Rep. Kim Eui-kyeom, prompt to the Herald that the U.S. spying revealed within the paperwork was “very intentional and premeditated,” whereas one other DPK politician, Rep. Youn Kun-young, accused Yoon of sharing the blame, saying that his relocation of the presidential office final Might “probably allowed the presidential workplace, the middle of energy and nationwide safety, to be spied on.”

Yoon is planning to go to Washington on April 26 to mark seven many years of alliance between the U.S. and South Korea, and his workplace denied the accusations that he bore any responsibility for the spying affair. A spokesperson for Yoon’s workplace informed reporters that “if there are forces attempting to magnify this incident forward of the South Korea-U.S. summit or distort it to undermine the alliance, they are going to face the resistance of many individuals.”

The state go to later this month would be the first to the U.S. by a South Korean president since 2011, coming because the Biden administration makes an attempt to shore up its relationships in an Indo-Pacific area fraught with safety issues from China to North Korea. The go to, based on the White Home, is supposed to deepen ties between the 2 nations. However a spying scandal simply weeks earlier than the summit could depart the nations’ friendship strained. Says Yang: “With the U.S.-Korea relations celebrating 70 years of alliance—that is sort of a catastrophe.”

Contact us at letters@time.com.