How The FTX Implosion Units Again the Bahamas Tech Scene

When FTX moved from Hong Kong to the Bahamas within the fall of 2021, many Bahamians hoped that the crypto change’s presence would remodel the island. “The Bahamas begins its rise as the subsequent international FinTech hub,” Prime Minister Philip Davis said on the firm’s opening ceremony on the island as he stood subsequent to former FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried. “The arrival of FTX is proof constructive that we’re headed in the appropriate route.”

A yr and a half later, FTX is gone following a stunning implosion, casting an extended shadow over the nation’s tech goals. Some Bahamian entrepreneurs and tech leaders argue there’s nonetheless loads of trigger for optimism, because of the nation’s regulatory incentives for companies and rising tech infrastructure. However others say that the FTX saga has made it tougher to persuade an already-wary public to embrace new types of monetary and technological innovation, together with the nation’s digital greenback.

“The Bahamas is all the time 5 to 10 years behind in know-how,” says Travis Miller, a Bahamian know-how and enterprise guide. “I believe it units us again from a know-how perspective as a result of I believe lots of people will likely be extra skeptical.”

‘FTX Will At all times Be Right here’

The Bahamas economic system has lengthy been reliant on tourism and offshore banking. Tourism and associated companies make up about 70% of the nation’s GDP, according to the Worldwide Commerce Administration. However Hurricane Dorian and COVID-19 each led to steep declines in guests and uncovered the fragility of this mannequin.

In the course of the coronavirus pandemic, the Bahamian authorities labored to make the nation extra interesting to fintech firms. In October 2020, the Bahamas turned the primary nation to situation a digital greenback, referred to as the SAND Greenback. The SAND Greenback is designed to all the time maintain the worth of a U.S. greenback. (The nation’s conventional foreign money, the Bahamian greenback, can also be pegged to the greenback.) The SAND Greenback is absolutely backed by the federal government and will be despatched and obtained over a cell phone without spending a dime in transactions comparable for customers to utilizing Paypal or Venmo, however and not using a third occasion middleman taking a processing payment.

In December 2020, the federal government handed the DARE (Digital Belongings and Registered Exchanges) Act, changing into one of many solely nations on the planet to set a licensing framework for crypto exchanges to legally arrange store. FTX was the primary firm to reap the benefits of the brand new measure, transferring from Hong Kong to the Bahamas in 2021.

Caroline Ellison, the CEO of FTX’s sister firm Alameda Analysis, wrote on an Effective Altruism forum in October 2021 that the corporate’s transfer to the Bahamas was “due primarily to the pleasant regulatory atmosphere” and a authorities that was “slicing again on purple tape.” Including to the enchantment was the truth that Bahamian firms would not have to pay taxes on earnings, capital beneficial properties, or wealth.

Whereas FTX stood to achieve considerably from the transfer, executives additionally promised that their presence would positively influence the Bahamas itself. “FTX belongs within the Bahamas. FTX will all the time be right here,” declared Valdez Okay. Russell, a Bahamian and the corporate’s new vice chairman of communications and company social accountability, in a radio interview with Nahaja Black in January 2022. “We will likely be an important a part of our financial development and contact the lives of each Bahamian, a method or one other.”

Many Bahamians, particularly these already concerned in tech and crypto, had been excited by FTX’s arrival. “Everybody was like, ‘Okay, we’ve got a giant canine right here now!’” Michael Armogan, the president of the Bahamas Esports Federation, instructed TIME. “Lots of people had been anticipating and wanting the Bahamas to develop into a tech hub.”

Across the similar time that FTX arrived, a co-working hub referred to as Crypto Isle additionally opened its doorways in Nassau, hoping to foster crypto training and entrepreneurship amongst Bahamians. Co-founder Davinia Bain says that whereas Crypto Isle’s efforts had been fully impartial from FTX, the change’s presence did improve native curiosity in cryptocurrencies.

“Life didn’t begin and finish with FTX. However after they did present up, it gave an enormous floodlight on crypto and blockchain within the Bahamas, and that floodlight benefited everyone within the area,” she says. ‘Among the bigger corporations, like accounting corporations, regulation corporations, and particular person service suppliers, had been like, ‘I have to rise up to hurry shortly: I would like to have the ability to provide my companies to new gamers within the area.’”

FTX and Bankman-Fried instantly began throwing their cash round in donations to native causes. There was a $500,000 donation to Lend A Hand Bahamas and $1.1 million given to a newly shaped Agricultural Growth Committee, with cash put aside for training and instruments for farmers. In January 2022, the corporate donated $1.5 million price of KN95 protecting masks and coronavirus testing kits to the Bahamian authorities. Many different native organizations obtained donations.

“FTX turned the gold mine, the brand new factor everybody needed to get a slice of,” Miller says. “A lot cash was flowing from them. However little to nobody was paying consideration when it comes to precisely how this cash was really being generated.”

Learn Extra: Where Did FTX’s Missing $8 Billion Go? Crypto Investigators Offer New Clues

Structural Change

However Bahamian entrepreneurs didn’t simply need to see charity: they needed to see lasting change, and to develop into built-in into this new tech ecosystem that FTX was constructing. Tyler Gordon, who was a part of the crypto-focused group Bahamas Masterminds, says that when FTX held an early meet-and-greet on the island, he pressed the corporate on its dedication to the island’s individuals. “That was a big concern that we had: this enormous firm was going to return in and get exceptions, leading edge infrastructure, and all that kind of stuff that Bahamians want every day, however are instructed that we will’t get,” he stated. Gordon and different crypto lovers needed to extra simply be capable to deposit and withdraw crypto through Bahamian banks, for instance, one thing that was restricted by the nation’s monetary establishments.

FTX pledged that it could rent Bahamians and assist the bigger inhabitants develop technical expertise. In January 2022, Russell stated that the corporate had already employed 40 Bahamians, engaged on compliance groups, safety, and authorized companies.

In April 2022, FTX hosted the Crypto Bahamas convention. It featured high-profile audio system like the previous U.S. president Invoice Clinton and a slew of celebrities together with Katy Perry and Orlando Bloom. As a result of the convention was invite-only, with tickets costing $3,000 and up, it was largely inaccessible to locals. However some discovered their means in, together with Lamont Astwood, one other Bahamas Masterminds member who signed up for a free move through the blockchain Solana’s hacker house. Astwood spent the weekend assembly entrepreneurs and studying about crypto, and even snapped a selfie with Bankman-Fried. “It was extravagant,” he says. “You’d get up, watch seminars all day, community, then select between pool events, nightclubs, seaside events. It was simply nonstop.”

The Crash

Slightly greater than seven months later, the occasion was over for Bankman-Fried: He was arrested by the Royal Bahamas Police Drive and extradited to the U.S. on expenses together with fraud and cash laundering. The lavish $60 million campus that Bankman-Fried had broken ground upon alongside Prime Minister Davis would lie dormant, and dozens of Bahamians employed by FTX out of the blue discovered themselves out of a job.

Miller says that FTX’s implosion in the end wasn’t shocking to him, as a result of “they had been spending cash so quick, it was virtually too good to be true.”

Some entrepreneurs additionally say that the FTX crash could also be having a unfavourable influence on the rollout of the Sand Greenback, the Bahamas’ digital foreign money. “Reputationally, it has affected us,” says Nicholas Rees, the CEO Kanoo Pays, a digital funds system that’s working to extend Sand Greenback adoption across the island. “The concern of know-how is one thing that we’ve needed to tackle considerably within the Bahamas and within the Caribbean [more broadly]. And when FTX collapsed, it made buyers and prospects take a look at know-how firms as a complete, significantly within the monetary companies area, with a sure stage of warning.”

Within the weeks earlier than FTX’s crash, its enterprise capital arm was about to announce an funding within the Kanoo Innovation Hub, a brand new incubator for tech and crypto entrepreneurs backed by Rees’s and Bain’s organizations. Rees says that FTX was planning to help within the funding of the entrepreneurs within the group’s first cohort. That provide evaporated together with the corporate. “The truth that they’d have an interest was an honor to us—and the home simply crumbled at the moment,” Rees says.

Nevertheless, Bain says that the Innovation Hub was “by no means financially modeled primarily based on a possible relationship with FTX,” and that this system continues to be carrying on as deliberate, with greater than 30 entrepreneurs nonetheless taking part of their inaugural program. Bain hopes that this system will spur Bahamians themselves to create their very own strong crypto infrastructure. “We have to guarantee there are extra Bahamian gamers so we don’t have this ‘key man’ threat, the place you may have one or two main gamers and if one thing goes improper, everyone’s considering the business is gonna go to hell,” she says.

Whereas rising Bahamian entrepreneurs are nonetheless laborious at work, Gordon says the prospect of adoption has slowed dramatically. He says that when he’s had latest conversations with politicians and bankers about crypto, they’ve responded with widespread skepticism. “It’s type of iffy as as to whether it could be possible for us to combine crypto into the rest,” he says,” and what that might realistically appear to be now that individuals have had the wool faraway from their eyes.”

Contact us at letters@time.com.